Philadelphia Checks Turkey Prices Instead of Balancing Its Checkbook

Every November, the Controller's office prices Thanksgiving dinner. Meanwhile $33M in missing variance, nearly $1B in accounting errors. This is a fucking joke.

Folded newspaper resting on an open city budget ledger with a turkey price tag.

Here's a hilarious report from the Philadelphia Controller's office, published every November: “The Cost of Thanksgiving Dinner: $78.92 for a Family of Ten.”

The team probably spent about $20,000 of taxpayer money driving around checking the price tags of turkeys, cranberries and potatoes — to put out a report that no one reads.

Meanwhile, this is the exact same institutional bureaucracy that went years without reconciling its main bank accounts, resulting in $33 million in missing variance and nearly a billion dollars in undetected accounting errors. This is a fucking joke, not a “tragic misallocation of resources.”

But the turkey report? That comes out every November. Like clockwork.

The Controller's office is supposed to be the people who watch the store. Who find the waste. Who sound the alarm when something smells off.

They're supposed to be the watchdogs who protect the $6.8 BILLION budget of our tax money.

We all like to do fun things — but play comes after work, particularly when the School District of Philadelphia is running a $300 million structural deficit of its own. That same district just paid out $650,000 to settle a lawsuit over its selective-school admissions overhaul — I covered that in $650K Settlement Settles Nothing at Philadelphia’s Selective Schools.

I'm not saying the cost of food doesn't matter. I'm saying that you can't be dicking around tracking cranberry prices for fifteen years, if you can't figure out your bank balance for three years on an $11.8B budget. The structural problem is laid out in The 2018 Audit Found $924 Million in Errors. The System Still Exists. — a watchdog that can diagnose but not treat, that the Mayor decides whether to feed.

Accountability is priceless — and apparently not expected. On the plus side, we know the cost of that same dinner is up 291% since 1974.

Sources

Note: The $300M structural deficit referenced in the body is the School District of Philadelphia's, not the City of Philadelphia's. The City of Philadelphia itself ended FY2025 with a $1.19B fund balance. The two budgets are separate.

Note: The Controller's reported 50-year change in the cost of a Thanksgiving dinner is 291% (from $17.05 in 1974 to $66.60 in 2024). The 2018 audit referenced in the body was issued by the City Controller's office; the unreconciled bank accounts it identified were a failure of the City Treasurer's office, a separately elected office.