281 Problems Reported. Zero Responses.

281 environmental complaints. Zero responses. Philadelphia School District schools are still closing for the same issues five years later.

Empty Philadelphia school hallway with peeling paint, flickering fluorescent light, and stained ceiling tiles.

I ran into a report last week that pissed me off. It was from the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, published in May 2021, and I hadn’t seen it surface in any of the recent coverage of Philadelphia’s school facilities crisis.

Two hundred and eighty-one.

That’s how many environmental complaints teachers and staff filed with the School District of Philadelphia in the two months after schools reopened in March 2021. Asbestos, lead paint, mold, broken ventilation. The kind of problems that make you wonder what’s in the air your children are breathing while they’re supposed to be learning long division.

Zero.

That’s how many the district responded to. Not “we’re looking into it.” Not “we’ve logged your complaint.” Not “the facilities team will be in touch.” Zero. The teachers had categorized 5% of the complaints as “immediate” — meaning the district had 24 hours to respond. 22% as “urgent” — 72 hours. 16% as “important” — 14 days. The district answered none of them. Chalkbeat confirmed the same numbers at the time.

In an October 2021 letter to PFT president Jerry Jordan, then-superintendent William Hite made the district’s case about the app: it “is not the District’s database for managing reports of facilities issues.” The union vets what comes in and sets the deadlines, so a report filed through the app can actually slow a fix down. He said the district had agreed to take app reports anyway, and had put someone in facilities on tracking them into its work order system. That’s a fair argument about what the app is. It isn’t an answer to the 281.

I keep thinking about the 281, because five years later, the district is still doing the same thing — except now the schools are actually closing.

Frankford High School was shut for the entire 2023-2024 school year because of damaged asbestos in a building more than a century old. Mitchell Elementary was closed in April 2023 after asbestos was found in the plaster. By the time the dust settled, six schools had been closed in 2022-2023 — Building 21, Mastery Simon Gratz, Frankford, C.W. Henry, Mitchell, Universal Vare. Another, Southwark Elementary, was the first to close in 2023-2024. The Inquirer has the full list. Frankford’s main building stayed shut through the 2024-2025 school year too, and only reopened for the 2025-2026 school year after $29.9 million in repairs. And Kensington High School didn’t open in its own building for the 2026-2027 school year — asbestos turned up while crews were replacing an old HVAC unit, so more than 400 students started the year at another school.

The 281 complaints weren’t noise. They were the early warning system. The district didn’t answer them, and the asbestos is still winning.

When a landlord did this, you’d call the housing authority. When a factory did this, you’d call the EPA. When a school district does it, you get a press release about “ongoing efforts” and a request for patience. Two hundred and eighty-one reports tried to tell someone their kids were breathing bad air. The district answered none of them. The lesson isn’t that the district is underfunded. The lesson is that the district knows it doesn’t have to answer to anyone.


Notes, Sources, and Methodology

Every number here comes out of a public document. The 281 and the zero are the PFT’s May 2021 facilities report, on page 11, and Chalkbeat confirmed both at the time. The closure list is the Philadelphia Inquirer’s. Frankford’s reopening is the district’s own announcement, and Kensington is Chalkbeat’s coverage. The District’s letter is Attachment 3 of the PFT’s December 2021 testimony to City Council, on page 42 — the PFT rebuilt its site and the original links now 404, so those two links go through the Internet Archive.

Methodology. The 281 is the union’s count of reports filed in the app in the two months after schools reopened in March 2021, and the response figures are as of the report’s publication in May 2021, not a current status. For the closures I matched each school to the school year students were actually displaced, which is not always the year the building shut, and I used the district’s own announcement where the district has published one.

Limitations. The closure record here is a floor, not a total. I could not find a single district-published list of buildings closed for asbestos, so the list reflects what press coverage and the district’s own announcements document. And the 281 are the union’s count from its own app, a source the District said was “not the District’s database for managing reports of facilities issues.”