The Good Side of 311 · Part 4 of 6

Parks and Rec's 74.9% 311 On-Time Rate Hides Two Different Operations

Philadelphia Parks and Rec looks fine on the agency level. Crack it open and street trees tell a different story — fast crew, brutal long wait.

Street trees (10,865 of 13,065 tickets)
10,865 tickets · 1.8-day median · worst 10% at 256 days
Park safety issues (2,200 of 13,065 tickets)
2,200 tickets · 19.1-day median · worst 10% at 175 days
Uniform 7-day bins — bar width is equal across the year, so bar height shows density (tickets per day).

Parks and Recreation closes 74.9% of its 311 tickets on time — on 13,065 closed tickets filed since 2024. That is the second-best rate among the big 311 agencies in the city, behind CLIP at 91.9%. On the dashboard, Parks and Rec looks fine.

The 74.9% is the average of exactly two kinds of tickets Parks and Rec handles. The first is park safety issues — broken benches, fallen trees across a path, holes in the ground, damaged playground fixtures. The second is dead, diseased, or leaning street trees. They are very different operations. The 74.9% headline is the average of those two shapes, and the average is the part the headline is hiding.

90.0%
Park safety issues closed on time — 2,200 tickets
71.8%
Street trees closed on time — 10,865 tickets

Park safety issues: where Parks and Rec is genuinely good

Park safety is the agency’s catch-all for safety and maintenance issues in parks. Parks and Rec closes those tickets on time 90.0% of the time on 2,200 closed calls — half inside three weeks, another 38% somewhere in the next five months, the unlucky 10% stretching to about six months. That is a service the department has chosen to staff: slow and mostly fine, with the worst case landing exactly where the city said it would.

Street trees: a fast crew bolted onto a long wait

Street trees is the agency’s biggest workload by five times — 10,865 closed tickets, more than four-fifths of everything Parks and Rec does. A typical call is about a tree that is dead, diseased, or leaning over a sidewalk. Parks and Rec closes those tickets on time 71.8% of the time, and on its face that looks fine.

The chart at the top of this article shows that it is not fine. Park safety is a gradual slope; Street Trees is a tall spike in the first week followed by a long tail of small bars that runs past a year. About two-thirds of the tickets close inside a week; about one in ten waits until somewhere around 256 days after the call.

What that shape means in practice. If you call 311 about a street tree, you will not get average service. Your ticket is most likely to close in about two days, or it is most likely to drag past three months. There is not a meaningful middle. The 71.8% on the dashboard is the average of those two outcomes — it tells you neither what is likely to happen to your ticket, nor whether the operation is actually working.

The dashboard misses the bimodality by construction. Half the tickets cluster at the fast end and push the on-time rate up; the other half is split between a thin band that closes inside the deadline and a fat tail of tickets that close past it. If the worst 10% of street trees stretched from eight months to sixteen months, the on-time rate would barely move — because the dashboard does not see past the worst 10%. The worst 10% is the measurement the city does not report, and it is the measurement that tells you whether the operation is working.

Why the agency-level number is the wrong number to watch

The 74.9% headline is the average of two operations that have almost nothing in common. Park safety is gradual and reliable; Street Trees is bimodal. The headline lands on 74.9% because Street Trees is five times the size of park safety, so the average pulls toward the Street Trees on-time rate. If the two were equal in size, the headline would land somewhere different — and the right read would land faster. Parks and Rec is two operations inside one agency, and the dashboard does not show which one you would land in.

If you call 311 about a street tree, the median ticket closes in two days. That is what the department is actually running. The other 10% — the part everyone complains about, the part that annoys us as residents of Philly — is not actually representative, on average or on the median, of the department’s real performance.


Where the data comes from

All data is the OpenDataPhilly 311 Service Requests table public_cases_fc: 13,065 closed Parks-and-Recreation tickets with a published SLA, filed 2024-01-01 through mid-2026. On-time means the closed timestamp lands inside the city’s published window, with business-day math for Business Days SLAs.

Limitations. The p90 is sensitive to long-tail ticket dating, and the dataset does not separate a “wait for crew” closure from a “stuck-in-queue” closure. Street Trees’ 256-day p90 overlaps with the city’s annual pruning cycle, which is the plausible mechanism for the long tail.